top of page

Tried Hypnosis for Performance Anxiety? Why the Calm Didn't Last

Nov 8
10 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

Dark slide with the title Tried Hypnosis for Performance Anxiety? Why the Calm Didn't Last, beside a watercolor of a swinging gold pocket watch
* Where I describe clients in my blog posts, I've changed names, instruments, and other identifying details to protect their privacy. Sometimes I'm describing one person, sometimes a pattern I've seen across several. The essence of the experience and what we worked on together remain true.


Quite a lot of the musicians who come to me have already tried hypnosis for their performance anxiety.


Some listened to recordings or apps on their own, often every night for weeks. Others worked with a hypnotherapist. And when I ask how it went, the story is remarkably similar.


It worked. In the moment, they felt calm, light, almost unrecognizable. For a day or two afterward, sometimes a little longer, the dread was gone.


And then it came back. The same thoughts, the same tight chest before a performance, the same sense of being watched. Within a few days it was as if nothing had happened.


The interesting part is what they make of that. Almost always, they conclude that something is wrong with them. Hypnosis works for other people. They must be the exception, too anxious, too stubborn, or somehow broken.


If that's your story, I'd like to offer a different explanation... because I don't think you're the problem.



Why I know what happens in those sessions


A small confession before we go further: I've trained in hypnotherapy myself.


Around the time of my MA research, I was determined to learn everything I could about approaches that might help with performance anxiety. Out of curiosity, I completed a hypnotherapy program and got a certificate in Ericksonian hypnotherapy. I didn't pursue it further. Shiny object syndrome, I suppose: Once I understood how it worked, my curiosity had already moved on to the next thing. But I know how a session is built, what the inductions and suggestions are designed to do, and why it can feel so good.


So this post looks at what hypnosis can and can't do for a performer, and what to make of it if the effect faded for you.



What hypnosis is


The definition used by the American Psychological Association's hypnosis division describes it as "a state of consciousness involving focused attention and reduced peripheral awareness characterized by an enhanced capacity for response to suggestion" (Elkins et al., 2015). (No swinging pocket watch required, despite what the cover image might suggest.) Hypnotherapy is the use of that state to work on a medical or psychological concern.


People differ a lot in how responsive they are to hypnosis. That responsiveness does predict who benefits, but only modestly (Montgomery et al., 2011). So if hypnosis didn't do much for you, that might tell us something about how you respond to one particular method, and nothing about whether your performance anxiety can change.



What the research shows for performance anxiety


The short answer: Not much yet.


As far as I could find, there are only two controlled studies of hypnosis for music performance anxiety, and both were with students.


  • Music students: In a study of 40 anxious music students, two sessions of hypnosis lowered performance anxiety compared with a control group, and the scores were even lower six months later (Stanton, 1994). It's an encouraging result, but a weak study. A major review rated its quality very low, and the author was testing his own method (Fernholz et al., 2019).

  • Pianists: In a study of 46 advanced pianists, two sessions of cognitive hypnotherapy reduced anxiety and improved expert ratings of their playing at a second concert. But on the pianists' own rating of their performance anxiety, hypnotherapy didn't beat the control group, while a different therapy did (Brooker, 2018).


Reviews of the treatment research agree that the evidence is thin. One concluded that for hypnotherapy, "more research is needed to clarify if weak evidence for positive effects on MPA can be confirmed" (Fernholz et al., 2019). Another describes the whole field of performance anxiety treatment as still "in its infancy" (Kinney et al., 2025).


None of these studies included professional orchestral musicians or opera singers. And none measured how people felt in the days after a session, or at a real audition.


(If you'd like the bigger picture on how common performance anxiety is and what the research supports most, I've collected it in Music Performance Anxiety Statistics.)



Recordings and apps


Most of my clients who tried hypnosis used recordings or apps on their own.


When researchers reviewed 407 hypnosis apps, none of them reported having been tested for effectiveness (Sucala et al., 2013). (407... That's a LOT of soothing voices.) A more recent review found that only a handful had been through any kind of clinical trial (Scheffrahn et al., 2025).


There's also a pattern in the research on self-hypnosis. Across 22 trials, self-hypnosis tended to help when someone first taught it as a skill, usually in a live session. The largest trials that relied on audio recordings alone found no effect (Eason & Parris, 2019).


So if you listened to a recording every night and the calm didn't carry into the concert hall, that's close to what we could expect based on this piece of research. It doesn't necessarily mean you did it wrong.


Also, the voice seems to matter too. One of the singers in my MA research had tried hypnotherapy before, and she mentioned that hypnotherapists usually send you some material first, so you get used to their voice before the actual session. In our work together, she didn't get on well with mindfulness recordings by a speaker she didn't know, and engaged much more with the ones I recorded personally, meaning it was in a voice she already knew from our sessions (Kutsal et al., 2024).


By the way, similar recordings are now part of my Performing Under Pressure program.



So why didn't it last?


Well, the research doesn't answer this directly.


For anxiety in general, the effects of hypnosis often hold up at follow-up, especially when it's combined with other psychological approaches (Valentine et al., 2019). So "hypnosis never lasts" isn't true.


But there are a few well-studied reasons why calm in a session can fade so quickly once you're back in real life.


Feeling calm isn't the same as learning something new


Research on fear and anxiety shows that lasting change comes from what you learn while the fear is present: That you can stay, that you can function, that the worst doesn't happen. How calm you feel during a session predicts much less (Craske et al., 2014).


Old fear also stays in the background, overlaid with new learning, and it tends to return in new or higher-stakes settings (Vervliet et al., 2013). A quiet room with a soothing voice is very different from a stage, a screen and a panel. So when the nerves return at the audition, that's the normal pattern of how fear works.


Trying to relax can backfire under pressure


In one set of experiments, people who were told to relax while under mental pressure actually became more physically aroused than people who weren't trying to relax at all (Wegner et al., 1997). If the goal of every session is to feel calm, then any anxiety on the day can start to look like failure, and fighting it makes it louder.


The recording can become something you need


This last one is my own observation more than a research finding. For some musicians, the recording or the session slowly becomes the thing that has to happen before they can perform. Research on so-called safety behaviors suggests that relying on something like this can get in the way of learning that you can cope without it (Blakey & Abramowitz, 2016).


(It's a similar trap to the one I described in Beta Blockers for Musicians.)



"Calm" isn't the same as "present"


Some of my clients used hypnosis right before an audition. They told me it helped them calm down a little. But they also told me that in hindsight, it didn't really improve how they performed.


When I asked why, one of them put it like this: They were just calm. Not engaged, not present, not really in the music.


That makes a lot of sense to me. A good performance needs energy, attention and a sense of what you want to say. Calm can be pleasant, but on its own it can also leave you a little flat, a little far away from the music. (That's more like a spa day, not opening night.)


And remember, anxiety and a good performance aren't opposites. In one study, pianists played better in front of an audience than alone, despite feeling more anxious (Hörster & Hansen, 2024).



What I suggest instead (or alongside)


If hypnosis helps you, there's no reason to stop. Like any tool, the useful question is whether it's doing the job you need it to do.


Here's what I'd suggest adding to your toolkit:


Practice with the nerves present


Instead of waiting until you feel calm, practice performing while the nerves are there. Mock performances, recording yourself, playing for a friend. This is where the lasting learning happens, and it's the same idea behind Practicing Mistakes on Purpose.


Know where your attention is going


On the day, a more useful question than "How calm am I?" is "Where is my attention?" If you've decided beforehand what you'll come back to, like the next phrase or the story you want to tell, you have somewhere to go when the thoughts get loud.



Treat the return of nerves as information


If the anxiety comes back after a session, nothing has gone wrong. It's a sign that this situation still matters to you, and that there's more to learn in it. That's very different from "It didn't work, so I'm the problem."



It didn't fail because of you


Frankly, the research on hypnosis for performers is thin, recordings on their own are the weakest form of it...


Plus, as I keep saying in sessions, calm on its own is never going to be enough for a performance.


The goal is to be able to perform with whatever you feel on the day, pleasant or not.



An invitation ☕️


If you've tried hypnosis or other approaches and you're still not sure what will help, a Performance Strategy Session is a good next step: One 90-minute session where we can look at what's happened so far and build a plan for your next performance or audition.




About


I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.




Quick answers


Does hypnosis work for performance anxiety?


It can help some people, but the evidence for musicians is thin. Two small studies with music students found reductions in anxiety, and reviews say more research is needed. No studies have included professional orchestral musicians or opera singers.


Why did hypnosis stop working for me?


Feeling calm during a session isn't what predicts lasting change. Fear tends to return in new, higher-stakes settings like auditions, and recordings used on their own are the weakest form of hypnosis. A fading effect doesn't mean something is wrong with you.


Are hypnosis apps and recordings effective?


Very few have been tested. A review of 407 hypnosis apps found that none reported being tested for effectiveness, and trials using audio recordings alone tended to find no effect.


Can hypnosis help right before an audition?


Some musicians find it calms them a little, but calm isn't the same as being engaged and present in the music. Anxiety and a good performance can also go together.



Research cited



Letters On 
Music, Practice & Mindset

Trusted by 300+ musicians in 19+ countries and counting...

34_edited.jpg
Kuki & Annie.png

Cute(ish) Tax:

The judgmental team

Absolutely no spam, and you can easily unsubscribe anytime. Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared with anyone. 

Every Tuesday morning, a Letter lands in your inbox — a short read with stories from the coaching studio, ideas worth thinking about, and the kind of perspective that helps you show up steadier on stage and off.

​

Sometimes I'll share a small gift, point you to a new piece I've written, or let you know when I'm opening up coaching spots or creating something you might want in on.

​

Oh... and you’ll get exclusive access to my cats’ most judgmental photos. Obviously.

bottom of page