top of page

The Trial Year: Why Winning the Orchestra Job Can Make the Nerves Worse (and What Helps)

Nov 12
8 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Dark slide with the title The Trial Year: Why Winning the Orchestra Job Can Make the Nerves Worse (and What Helps), beside a watercolor of an egg balanced on a spoon.
* Where I describe clients in my blog posts, I've changed names, instruments, and other identifying details to protect their privacy. Sometimes I'm describing one person, sometimes a pattern I've seen across several. The essence of the experience and what we worked on together remain true.

You'd think winning the audition would be the moment the pressure lifts...


After all, you prepared for months, got through the rounds, and they chose you.


Then the trial starts, and many of the musicians I work with find something they didn't expect: Every rehearsal starts to feel like an audition, and so do the concerts and even the chats in the corridor.


Only now it doesn't last a day. It lasts a season, or two.


If you've won the job and feel more nervous than you did before it, there are very good reasons for this.



How trial periods work


The details depend on where you are.


In the US, a new member usually starts on probation for one or two years (Pompe & Tamburri, 2021). A committee of tenured colleagues reviews them along the way, and the final decision rests with the music director in most orchestras. The musicians' union's current model recommends that the first full season be probationary, with three reviews and a secret ballot at the end (American Federation of Musicians, 2024).


In Germany, the trial usually lasts one season, and at top orchestras like the Berlin Philharmonic it can be two (Hanssen, 2024). It ends with a vote, often needing a two-thirds majority, and in many orchestras the section and the music director each have a veto (Greenleaves, 2016).


In the UK, it often looks different again. Several musicians may be invited to trial in turn, and trials have sometimes gone on for more than three years (Classic FM, 2025).


Across countries, a survey of 119 orchestras found that about two-thirds had trial periods of 6 to 12 months, with exactly 12 months the most common (McBain, 2008).


What nobody publishes is how many people don't pass. A US advocacy group writes that "the vast majority" of orchestral musicians receive tenure (Black Orchestral Network, 2024), while a German newspaper says the number who have to leave in the end "is not small at all" (Hanssen, 2024). So I can't give you a percentage here, and I'd suspect it varies too greatly to generalize anyway.



Why it can feel harder than the audition


Every rehearsal becomes an audition


An audition is one day. A trial is months of being heard by the people who will decide whether you stay.


Research on stress backs up how hard that is. A review of 208 studies found that tasks where people were judged by others, in a situation they couldn't control, produced the largest stress-hormone response of all, and it took longer to settle afterward (Dickerson & Kemeny, 2004). A trial year is that combination, repeated every working day.


It's pass or fail, with nothing in between


In a way, that's true. At the end of the trial, you either get the job or you don't. But if you carry that black-and-white view into every rehearsal, each small slip feels like it could decide everything, and nobody can live like that for a season without burning out.


Not knowing what people really think


Your new colleagues are friendly. But are they being nice to your face and saying something else behind your back? In many US orchestras, any member can pass comments to the committee anonymously (Edgers, 2024), so the worry has some basis.


A percussionist who went through three years of probation with a major US orchestra described what the silence did to him: "Then the performance anxiety comes back because these people aren't telling me what they think" (Dorris, 2012).


Fitting in, socially as well as musically


In Germany, colleagues use the trial to judge whether a newcomer fits in "both artistically and personally" (Hanssen, 2024). That's a lot to carry if you've just moved country, which most of the orchestral musicians I work with have. Many are working far from where they grew up, sometimes in a new language.


Research on starting a new job points the same way. How well newcomers settle in depends on knowing what's expected of them, trusting their own ability, and feeling accepted by the people around them (Bauer et al., 2007). In a trial, the people you need to feel accepted by are also the ones voting on you.


Comparing yourself


Comparison has plenty to work with: The person who held the job before you, the colleague everyone seems to love, or, in a UK-style trial, the other candidates trialing for the same chair.


"I don't really deserve this"


This one comes up most when it's someone's first permanent job, maybe after years of freelancing. Part of them is waiting to be found out. Feelings like this are common among high achievers, and they're linked to anxiety and burnout (Bravata et al., 2020). It may also help to know that in a study of all of Australia's full-time orchestras, the youngest musicians were significantly more anxious than the oldest ones (Kenny et al., 2014). Being new is hard, and it tends to get better over time. Too bad we can't fast-forward to a time when it gets easier like in the movies :)



What helps


Here's what I suggest to the musicians I work with:


Let one rehearsal be one rehearsal


The vote is at the end of the trial, not at the end of every rehearsal. A rough day or a cracked note is part of a season, the way it is for every tenured player around you. When you notice yourself treating today as the verdict, remind yourself which shade of gray it actually is. (I'm told there are more than 50! :) )


Find a few allies


Look for one or two colleagues you trust, preferably people who've been in the orchestra a while, and ask them for honest feedback. Specific questions get better answers than "How am I doing?": Was that entry where you wanted it? Is there anything about how I blend in the soft passages you'd change?


When there's no feedback, don't fill the silence with the worst case


Silence often means people are busy, or that nothing needed saying. If you'd like to know where you stand, ask, through your allies, your section leader or whatever formal reviews your orchestra has. Then base your picture on what you actually hear.


Invest in the social side, beyond the job


Go for the coffee after rehearsal, join the occasional dinner, learn the names of the people in the next section. If you've moved country, build a life outside the orchestra too, so the job isn't carrying everything. Becoming a colleague people actually know makes the whole year feel less like a trial.


Keep a tiny journal


This is one of my favorites. After each rehearsal or concert, write down a few things that went well, and one small thing to improve next time. Keep it tiny, something like a 1% change, and make it concrete: Breathe earlier before the entry at letter D, not Play better. It isn't a list of everything you did wrong. Over a season, it becomes a record of everything you've built, which is very useful on the days the impostor feelings get loud.


Keep your attention on today


The vote is months away, and thinking about it now won't help you perform better. What you can do is prepare well for this week's program, listen to the section, and bring your best to tonight's concert. That's also what the people voting will remember.



If it doesn't work out


Sometimes, despite everything, a trial ends without the job. When that happens, it's a real professional setback...


A flutist who wasn't kept after her trial year wrote about it publicly: "Failing hurts. Not being enough hurts." In the same letter, she said she was also "relieved that this time of not knowing is over" (Boulègue, 2019).


A trial decision is about one orchestra, one section and one season, and many musicians who don't pass go on to win other jobs. When an Orchestra Audition Ends With No Hire looks at how much of these decisions has little to do with you.



The year after the audition


Winning the job is the start of a different kind of performance, one that lasts a season or more and happens in front of the same people every day. It makes sense that it feels harder than the audition. With a few allies, a less black-and-white view of each day and a small record of what's going well, it can become something you live through as yourself.


You were chosen for a reason. The trial is your chance to settle into that, one rehearsal at a time.



An invitation ☕️


If you've just won a job, or you're in the middle of a trial and finding it harder than the audition, private coaching is where we'd work on this together over the season, from the first rehearsal to the vote.





About


I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.




Quick answers


How long is an orchestra trial period?


It depends on the country and the orchestra. In the US, probation usually lasts one to two years. In Germany it's usually one season, and up to two at top orchestras. A survey of 119 orchestras found most trials last 6 to 12 months.


How do you pass an orchestra trial or probation?


There's no formula, since colleagues judge both musical and personal fit. It helps to find a few trusted colleagues to ask for feedback, to invest in the social side, and to focus on each week's work instead of treating every rehearsal as the final verdict.


What happens if you don't pass the trial year?


You leave the orchestra at the end of the trial. It can be very painful, but it reflects one orchestra's decision at one point in time, and many musicians who don't pass go on to win other positions.


Is it normal to be anxious during the trial year?


Yes. Being evaluated by colleagues day after day is one of the most stressful situations people face, and many musicians find the trial harder than the audition.



Research cited



Letters On 
Music, Practice & Mindset

Trusted by 300+ musicians in 19+ countries and counting...

34_edited.jpg
Kuki & Annie.png

Cute(ish) Tax:

The judgmental team

Absolutely no spam, and you can easily unsubscribe anytime. Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared with anyone. 

Every Tuesday morning, a Letter lands in your inbox — a short read with stories from the coaching studio, ideas worth thinking about, and the kind of perspective that helps you show up steadier on stage and off.

​

Sometimes I'll share a small gift, point you to a new piece I've written, or let you know when I'm opening up coaching spots or creating something you might want in on.

​

Oh... and you’ll get exclusive access to my cats’ most judgmental photos. Obviously.

bottom of page