"Work on Your Confidence": What That Audition Feedback Means (and What to Do With It)
Updated: 1 day ago

This one has been on my mind for a while, and I want to talk about it the way I would if you were sitting across from me with a cup of tea.
You prepared for months. You knew the excerpts inside out, you did the mock auditions, you got through the day in one piece. And then the email arrives:
"Thank you for coming. The panel felt you should work on your confidence."
And you're sitting there thinking: How, exactly?
If you've ever had that feedback (or something close to it, like "more presence" or "be more convincing"), I want you to know two things right away.
It's one of the most common pieces of feedback I hear from the musicians I work with, and the frustration you feel about it makes complete sense.
Why "work on your confidence" is such frustrating feedback
Here's my problem with it...
Confidence isn't something you can practice the way you practice a passage. You can't take it to the practice room, slow it down, put a metronome on it and bring it back up to tempo.
In fact, "work on your confidence" is a bit like a doctor telling you to try to be less ill. It describes the problem, and it gives you nothing to do about it.
So most musicians do the only thing that seems possible: They try to feel more confident. They read the books, write the affirmations, tell themselves they've got this.
(I've had so many clients come to me after months of affirmations, mindset work and positive self-talk that left the underlying pattern completely untouched.)
You were handed a vague word and did your best with it. I mean, that's all anyone can do with feedback like that.
What the panel probably heard
Panels rarely have time to write long feedback, so they reach for the nearest word.
"Confidence" is that word surprisingly often.
In my experience, it usually points to something you can hear and see. For example:
Playing it safe. The dynamics got smaller, the phrases stayed polite, and the risks you take in the practice room stayed in the practice room.
Getting through it. You were managing the excerpt from the outside, checking each note as it left you, and judging yourself through the eyes of the panel before they even had the chance.
Holding back physically. A smaller sound, a shorter breath, eyes on the floor between excerpts, a rushed start because waiting felt unbearable.
(If you'd like more on this, I wrote about what audition panels listen for beyond technical perfection and about why audiences see before they hear.)
But notice how none of these mean you lack confidence as a person.
They're what a well-prepared musician tends to do when a part of their mind decides the room is dangerous and starts protecting them.
Why you can't think your way into confidence
The tricky part is that what happens to you in an audition room has mental, emotional and physical sides all at once. Your thoughts speed up, your body gets ready for a threat, and your attention starts watching you instead of the music.
You can't talk yourself out of all that in the thirty seconds before you walk in. And waiting to feel confident before you play freely tends to be a very long wait.
What helps is building the skill of performing well while you're unsure. That's a skill you can practice, and it's the one I'd want you to work on. I wrote more about it in Performance Confidence: What It Is and How Musicians Build It.
What to do with the feedback
So here's how I'd take a vague word and turn it into something you can work on:
1. Translate it into concrete moments
If you have a recording of your audition (or of your mock auditions), listen back with one question in mind: Where did I play it safe? Write down the moments. Maybe the opening of the second excerpt, maybe every soft entry, or maybe it was the last thirty seconds when you were tired. Now you have something specific instead of a whole personality trait to fix.
If you feel comfortable, you can also write back to the orchestra and politely ask whether they could point to a moment or two. Not every panel will reply, but when they do, it's gold.
2. Practice performing, as well as playing
You've probably heard me talk about this before...
Most of our practice time goes into the music itself. Very little goes into playing it while someone is listening, judging, and holding your future in their hands (no pressure!).
So build that in on purpose: Play your list for a colleague, record a full run without stopping, do a mock audition with someone you slightly don't want to impress. It'll probably feel uncomfortable, but that just means you're working the right mental muscles.
3. Decide where your attention goes before you walk in
Under pressure, your attention will go to the panel, the mistakes and your heartbeat unless you give it somewhere better to go.
Before the next audition, choose one quality you want to bring into the room, like a big, generous sound or real commitment to the character of each excerpt. When your mind wanders (and it will), keep bringing it back to that.
What "work on your confidence" might be telling you
I'll leave you with something I've seen many times:
Very often, when a panel writes "confidence", they heard something in you that you didn't fully let them hear.
They noticed the musician underneath the careful version. (We can call it "potential" if you'd like.)
So a lot of the time, what they're really asking for is conviction. Committing to your musical choices and being willing to stand out for them, knowing that not everyone in the room will agree with every one of them.
That's a risk, yes, but it's the kind of risk that makes a panel lean in.
When you're trying to please everyone, the playing gets careful, and careful playing tends to sound small, however well prepared it is.
That might be frustrating to hear, I know, but I think it's also hopeful in a way.
The thing they wanted more of is already yours. The next step is simply about letting more of it into the room.
An invitation ☕️
If you have another audition coming up, a Performance Strategy Session is one 90-minute session where we can turn that feedback into a plan together, so you know what you're working on and how you'll handle the nerves on the day.
About
I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.
Quick answers
What does "work on your confidence" mean in audition feedback?
Usually it means the panel heard you holding back: Playing it safe, managing the music instead of performing it, or a smaller sound and presence than your preparation suggests. It's rarely a judgment of your personality, and it points to specific moments you can find and work on.
Can you practice confidence for auditions?
Not directly, but you can practice the skill underneath it: Performing well while you feel unsure. Mock auditions, full recorded runs and choosing your focus before you walk in all build that skill.
Should I ask the panel for more detailed feedback?
You can, politely, by asking whether they could point to a moment or two. Some panels won't have time to reply, but when they do, it turns a vague word into something specific.
Do affirmations help with audition confidence?
For many musicians, affirmations alone don't change what happens under pressure, because the pattern sits in attention and the body as much as in thoughts. Practicing performing under realistic conditions tends to help more.








