The Extroverted Musician: When Loving the Stage Isn't Enough
Updated: 5 days ago

I have to admit I'm an introvert, and most of the musicians I work with are introverts too...
So when an extroverted client books a session, it's an interesting experience: They bring a completely different energy into the room, and I love working with them.
Extroverts tend to come to performing from a different place. For many introverts, a concert is something to prepare for and recover from. For many extroverts, it's the part they look forward to.
That sounds like an advantage, and often it is. But it comes with its own set of challenges, and they're easy to miss, because from the outside, it looks like you should be fine.
What I mean by extroverted
In everyday language, an extrovert is someone outgoing and sociable.
In psychology (where it's usually spelled extraversion), it's more about where your energy comes from. Extroverts tend to be energized by people, activity and stimulation. Introverts tend to need more quiet time to recharge.
One long-standing theory is that extroverts have a lower baseline level of arousal in the brain, so they look for more stimulation to feel at their best. Introverts start from a higher baseline and reach their limit sooner.
(The classic demonstration involved putting drops of lemon juice on people's tongues. Apparently, the introverts salivated more (Eysenck & Eysenck, 1967). Science has a lot of weird ways to measure personality, and this is one of my favorites.)
None of this is fixed or all-or-nothing. Most people fall somewhere in the middle, and everyone can act out of character when something matters to them.
How it helps on stage
With my extroverted clients, a few things show up again and again:
They look forward to the stage. Performing energizes them, so a concert is something to look forward to, instead of something they have to save up energy for.
They feed off the audience. The room, the people, the reactions: All of it gives them something to play to. The performance comes alive when there's someone on the other side of it.
They recover more quickly after a run of performances. Where an introvert might need a few quiet days after a busy week of concerts, extroverts often bounce back sooner, because the performances themselves gave them energy.
There's some research support for the advantage, too. In a study of 393 orchestral musicians and choir singers, the musicians with the fewest performance anxiety symptoms and the most confidence in their ability to cope tended to score higher in extraversion, and lower in neuroticism (Spahn et al., 2024).
But that's a tendency across a group. It describes averages, and it doesn't stop an individual extrovert from getting nervous.
Which brings us to the tricky part...
Where it gets tricky
The practice room feels flat
Long practice periods can drain extroverts. And beyond the energy, many of them say they don't feel fully like themselves when they're alone in the practice room. The music can be exactly the same, but it only really comes alive when they're interacting with people.
(A bit like rehearsing a joke in front of the mirror. The words and gestures are all there, but it still feels like something is missing.)
Funnily enough, this is the part I can relate to, as an introvert. Some of my introverted clients describe it too. The difference is that many introverts can also enjoy making music completely on their own. Extroverts tend to need the other person, or the audience, to get there.
The audition room
Now think about an audition. A quiet room, a panel you can't see behind a screen, very little feedback, and no audience to play to.
For someone who feeds off the energy of the room, that's a strange situation. The very thing that usually makes their performance come alive is missing.
(Hard to feed off the energy of a folding screen.)
(By the way, I wrote more about why auditions feel so different from concerts in Why Auditions Feel Worse Than Concerts.)
"But I love performing. Why am I nervous?"
Extroverts often assume they shouldn't feel nervous. They love being on stage, people have told them they're natural performers, and so when nerves or self-conscious thoughts show up, it comes as a surprise.
That surprise can make things harder. It's one thing to feel nervous... but another thing to feel nervous and also think "this isn't supposed to happen to me".
Loving the stage and feeling nervous on it can coexist.
Being told you're "too much"
Many extroverted musicians have heard some version of this:
Too loud, too big, too much... in lessons, in sections, in feedback after a performance, basically in a lot of places, in a lot of different ways.
Often it's about the context. What a solo recital asks for is different from what a section of the second violins asks for.
And calibrating has another side. Sometimes you need to show how big you can go, so that you're hired for the bigger stages you're aiming for. Even on a small stage, it's worth showing that you're capable of the big one, instead of automatically shrinking to the size of the room you're in.
The energy itself is an asset (one that many introverts would trade a lot to have). The question is where to point it, how much the situation needs, and what you'd like it to show about where you're going next.
Saying yes to everything
Some extroverts want to do everything: Every project, every collaboration, every invitation.
It's energizing at the time... and then, a few weeks later, it all catches up with them at once.
For some musicians, this overlaps with ADHD, which is a slightly different story (I wrote about that in ADHD in Professional Musicians.) Of course, that doesn't mean all extroverts have ADHD :) I just see the same pattern with extroverts too.
There's an interesting finding that fits here. In one study, acting in a more extraverted way, being talkative, sociable and assertive, went with a better mood in the moment, but with more fatigue about three hours later (Leikas & Ilmarinen, 2017). So even if the energy is real at the time, tiredness can come afterward.
What helps
Here's what I tend to work on with extroverted musicians:
Climb the performance ladder. In my Performing Under Pressure program, there's a step-by-step approach I call the performance ladder. You start by performing for a stuffed animal, then a pet, then a trusted person, then a few trusted people, and so on.
(Stuffed animals make a very supportive audience. They never check their phones or look impatient.)
For extroverts, the early steps do two things. First, they strengthen your imagination for the times when you have to perform for no one. Second, you can bring that stuffed animal, or a photo, with you and pretend you're performing to a person or a group. Either way, the imagined audience is often the missing piece that makes practice feel like performing.
Bring the audience into the audition room. We also practice performing for an imaginary audience in a quiet room, the way it will feel at an audition. That way, the empty room becomes familiar, and you have someone to play to, even when no one is visibly there.
Use the warm-up room, if it energizes you. If talking to people helps you feel like yourself, walk around and socialize before you play. You don't need to sit in a corner with headphones because that's what everyone else is doing.
Expect the nerves. If you know that loving performing and feeling nervous can go together, the nerves are less of a surprise when they show up, and you can plan for them.
Plan for the comedown. If you tend to say yes to everything, look at your calendar as a whole, including the weeks after a busy stretch, and leave room for the fatigue that comes later.
Before you go
Being an extrovert is a real advantage on stage. You're drawn to performing, you feed off the people in the room, and you bounce back quickly...
The challenges show up in the places where that energy has nothing to work with: The practice room, the audition screen, the moment the nerves arrive anyway. Those are all things you can prepare for, so your energy is accessible when you need it, wherever you're playing.
An invitation ☕️
If you're an extroverted musician with an audition or a big performance coming up, a Performance Strategy Session is one 90-minute session where we can look at what gives you energy, where it runs out, and build a plan that works for the way you perform.
About
I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.
Quick answers
Do extroverted musicians get performance anxiety?
Yes. Research suggests extraversion is linked to slightly lower performance anxiety on average, but it doesn't prevent it. Many extroverts are surprised by nerves because they love performing.
Why do extroverted musicians struggle in auditions?
Extroverts often feed off the audience's energy. In an audition, with a screen and very little feedback, that source of energy is missing, so the performance can feel flat.
How can extroverted musicians practice more effectively?
Practicing with an imagined audience can help the practice room feel more like a performance, and practicing for an imagined audience in a quiet room helps prepare for auditions.
Can introverts be good performers too?
Yes. Many introverts come alive on stage, and some extroverts struggle with it. Personality shapes where your energy comes from. How well you perform depends on much more than that.
Research cited
Eysenck, S. B. G., & Eysenck, H. J. (1967). Salivary response to lemon juice as a measure of introversion. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 24(3), 1047–1053. https://doi.org/10.2466/pms.1967.24.3c.1047
Leikas, S., & Ilmarinen, V.-J. (2017). Happy now, tired later? Extraverted and conscientious behavior are related to immediate mood gains, but to later fatigue. Journal of Personality, 85(5), 603–615. https://doi.org/10.1111/jopy.12264
Spahn, C., Krampe-Heni, F., Hohagen, J., Immerz, A., & Nusseck, M. (2024). Personality traits in musicians with different types of music performance anxiety. Frontiers in Psychology, 15, Article 1398095. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1398095








