Listening Back to Your Own Recordings (Without Tearing Yourself Apart)
Updated: 7 days ago

Let me tell you about the most embarrassing recording I've ever listened to.
Years ago, I trained to be a radio host. But before we could go live on air, we had to get microphone and elocution training... so we recorded ourselves constantly and listened back with a very critical ear.
I improved a lot over those months, and a lot of it was simply uncomfortable.
You see, I wanted to come across as a serious person. At first, I tried copying the cute, flirty style I kept hearing from other hosts (women especially), and it didn't work at all, because that isn't who I am.
So I swung to the opposite end and went serious, almost solemn, more like an emotionally neutral news broadcaster than a radio host.
A few weeks into being live on air, I finally got hold of recordings of my own shows. And listening back was... horrifying.
I wasn't sounding serious. I sounded like I was scolding someone. (And it didn't help that I was freaking out every time the mic light was on, so there's that too.)
I felt humiliated, so embarrassed that I wanted to dig a hole and disappear, and I seriously considered not continuing.
I know how lucky I am when I say I had a few trusted friends who encouraged me to keep going and helped me sound more like a normal human being. They showed me some different ways of speaking, and my next shows were much, much better. And once I could hear what wasn't working, I could make a lot of the changes myself.
Here's what I pieced together a decade later:
The recording itself was useful. What nearly made me quit was how I listened to it.
If you're a musician, I suspect you know this feeling very well.
The 1am listen
You've just had a concert or an audition. It's late, you're tired, you're still a bit raw from the whole thing, and the recording is sitting right there on your phone.
So you press play, and you start hunting.
It never feels like self-sabotage in the moment. It feels responsible, as if you're being diligent, reviewing, taking notes.
But there's a big difference between listening back to learn something and listening back to confirm a verdict you've already reached.
Late at night, it's almost always the verdict. And if you're hunting for evidence against yourself, you'll always find some.
One of the first things I tell my clients is that the recording isn't the problem, and neither is reviewing it. It's who you're listening as. At 1am, it's going to be the harshest version of you. Give it a day, and you can listen as a musician gathering information.
Why we avoid pressing record at all
Then there's the other side of it: Not recording in the first place.
So many musicians spend weeks preparing for an audition without pressing record once. They practice the same excerpts over and over, making tiny adjustments, telling themselves they're being thorough. And they promise themselves they'll record tomorrow, after one more session, when they're ready.
If that's you, there's a good reason for it. Your mind has linked listening back with a very specific kind of pain: Hearing the gap between what you imagined and what came out. For a lot of classically trained musicians, that gap has been pointed out (and used against them) for years.
So your mind and body do what they do when they sense danger. They create distance. You might even notice it before you've played a note: A slight tightening in your chest, your focus narrowing, a sudden awareness of every finger or every breath. You start monitoring yourself before the music has even started.
(Plus, that long-awaited "ready" never quite arrives, because it's less about how prepared you are and more about a feeling of safety that nobody taught you how to build. But I digress.)
The ancient software in your head
When I think back to that radio recording, what strikes me most is how strongly my mind insisted I had to feel horrible.
Which led me to a theory about the critical part of our minds: It believes that if you feel bad enough (utterly embarrassed, ready to disappear), you'll finally make the change.
It's incredibly human. All of us carry that kind of ancient software, built to keep us in line and out of trouble.
The problem is that it's also completely unnecessary, especially when listening back to yourself is going to be part of your job for the rest of your career.
You can't make yourself feel horrible day after day just so you can improve. Sooner or later, you stop pressing play, or you stop doing the thing you love.
When you don't have a constructive way of approaching a recording, the critical mind fills the gap with harshness... so the answer is to give yourself that constructive way.
Simple enough, right? :)
Turns out, not so much. Because most musicians I work with were never taught how to listen constructively.
A gentler way to listen back
Here's what I suggest to the musicians I work with. As always, these are experiments: Keep what helps and drop the rest.
1. Record, close the file, walk away
Separate recording from evaluating. They don't have to happen in the same session, or even on the same day. Press record, play, close the file, and go and make a cup of tea. You're teaching yourself that pressing record doesn't automatically mean you're about to be graded.
2. Choose when you listen
Pick a time when you're rested and not still inside the performance: The next morning, the next day, sometimes even later. If you notice the 1am urge, you can tell yourself, "I'll listen tomorrow, when I can hear it properly."
3. Listen with three questions
When you do press play, listen for just three things: One thing that didn't work, one thing to look at more closely, and one thing you did well.
That last one is not optional. And yes, you need to find something you did well, even on the days you really don't feel like it. It's how you learn to do the good things again, and it keeps the harsh listener from taking over the whole session.
4. Borrow a trusted ear
My friends' help is what turned my radio recordings from humiliating into useful. A colleague or teacher you trust can hear things you can't yet, and they usually hear them far more kindly than you would. Choose someone who makes you curious about your playing, and also feels safe to share your imperfect moments with.
If you'd like to take this a step further, the recording-review step in what to do with "work on your confidence" feedback shows how to turn what you hear into specific moments to practice. And if the gap between your practice room and the stage is what you keep hearing, Why Can't I Perform Like I Practice? is a good next read.
Listening as a musician
The recording will always show you the gap between what you imagined and what came out. That's what recordings are for.
What you get to choose is who's doing the listening: The scolding voice I heard on my radio tapes, or a musician who's curious, rested, and interested in what comes next. The second one is the one who improves.
An invitation ☕️
If recording and listening back have become something you dread, a Performance Strategy Session is one 90-minute session where we can build a way of reviewing your playing together, so you can learn from your recordings without dreading them.
And if you'd like a simple structure for reviewing your practice, The Practice Pack includes a Reflect & Grow toolkit for exactly that.
About
I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.
Quick answers
Why do I hate listening to recordings of myself playing or singing?
Usually because you're hearing the gap between what you imagined and what came out, and your mind has learned to treat that gap as a threat. For singers there's an extra layer: You normally hear your own voice partly from inside your head, so a recording can sound unfamiliar at first.
Should I listen to my performance recording straight away?
It's usually better to wait until you're rested. Right after a performance, especially late at night, most musicians listen to confirm a harsh verdict. The next day, it's easier to listen for useful information.
How should musicians listen back to their recordings?
Separate recording from evaluating, choose a rested moment, and listen with three questions: One thing that didn't work, one thing to look at more closely, and one thing you did well.
Why do I avoid recording myself before an audition?
Pressing record means facing evidence of how you sound, and for many musicians that has been linked with criticism for years. Recording regularly in low-stakes sessions, without evaluating straight away, makes it feel more neutral over time.








