Ideas We've Normalized About Being a "Real" Musician (That Are Just Not Normal)
Updated: 4 days ago

Every sentence in this post is something I've heard in sessions. Usually more than once, and usually said in a very matter-of-fact way, as if it's written somewhere in the job description, between "bring a pencil" and "know your excerpts".
They sound reasonable at first. Then you hear them out loud, and you start to notice how much musicians have been asked to accept as "just part of being a musician".
Many of these are common in the music world, yes.
But common and normal are two different things. Something can be everywhere in a profession and still be worth questioning.
So here are six I hear most often, where I think they come from, and a small experiment for each one. You can take your music very seriously and still question every one of them.
1. "Crying in the practice room is just part of musician life"
We'd be worried if a friend said this about any other job. If an accountant told you they cried at their desk most weeks, you wouldn't say, "Ah, that's just accounting".
In music, it often gets a knowing nod. Many of us learned to practice in conservatoires and studios where struggle was a sign of commitment. The longer and harder it felt, the more serious you were. So tears in the practice room started to look like proof that you cared enough.
Frustration is part of learning anything difficult. A hard passage can bring you close to tears once in a while, and that's so human. What I'd look at is the pattern.
When practice regularly ends in tears, it has usually stopped being practice and turned into something closer to a trial. Every wrong note gets a verdict, and the verdict is about you.
Here's a small experiment. The next time you feel it building, pause and ask yourself: "On a scale of 1 to 10, how much of this is about the passage, and how much is about what I'm telling myself about the passage?" Then take a short break before you go back. A few minutes with a glass of water by a window is enough. If it doesn't help, feel free to drop it.
If this one speaks to you, What Music School Taught You About Worth looks at where this pattern often starts.
2. "I play better when nobody's listening, so I'm just not a performer"
Of course you play differently when someone's listening. Being heard changes what's happening in your body and where your attention goes. A part of your mind starts watching you play, and that's a lot to carry while you're also trying to make music.
Staying with the music while you're being heard is its own skill. Most musicians have spent thousands of hours practicing the music and very few practicing being listened to. So the gap between the practice room and the stage tells you something about your training.
It says nothing about who you are.
It's also rarely about "listening" in general. Often it's about specific listeners. One pianist I worked with could play church services for an audience without professional musicians in it, and she wasn't anxious at all. Put professionals in the audience, a composer in the seats or a respected musician at the back, and it was a different story. Her mind had learned to treat certain listeners as judges. (You can read her story here.)
The experiment: Practice being heard in small doses. Play one piece for a friend who isn't a musician, one for a colleague you trust, and record one as if it's a real performance. Notice which listener changes things most for you. That's really useful information.
For more on the gap itself, see Why Can't I Perform Like I Practice?
3. "I can't say I did well. That would be arrogant"
Saying what went well is simply accurate. It's also how you learn to do it again. If you only ever review what went wrong, you end up with a very detailed map of your mistakes and almost no record of what works.
You'd never call your favorite artist arrogant for saying they were happy with a concert. You'd probably think, "Good. They should be."
I hear this one a lot from musicians who grew up being told not to show off, or in cultures where "the nail that sticks out gets hammered down". The saying means that whoever stands out gets pushed back in line, like a nail that's tapped flat so the surface stays smooth. (I wrote a whole post about it: The Nail That Sticks Out.)
Modesty can be lovely, but a rule that you're never allowed to notice your own good playing goes well beyond modesty.
The experiment: After your next rehearsal or performance, write down three things. One that didn't work, one to look at more closely, and one you did well. Yes, even on the days you really don't feel like it. The one you did well is not optional :)
4. "I'll start enjoying it once I'm actually good"
You're already good enough to be on stages and in rooms most people never reach.
And "good enough" has a habit of moving every time you get close. You win the position, and suddenly good enough means passing trial. You pass trial, and now it means sounding like the colleague next to you.
So if enjoyment waits for good enough, it can wait for a whole career.
I worked with a horn player in her thirties who was performing over 200 concerts a year with a major orchestra. From the outside, her career looked exactly the way the dream says it should look. She had stopped enjoying making music.
Underneath, we found a belief she'd picked up early in her training:
To be a serious musician, you let go of play. Enjoying yourself was an occasional bonus, at best.
Early on in our sessions, she wrote to me: "I picked up an old favorite and realized I was already enjoying it." It might read like a casual sentence, I know... but for someone who'd spent years performing as a job, and a job alone, it was a big one. (Her full story is here.)
The experiment: Once a week, play something just because you love it. Don't record it, and don't fix anything. If a part of your mind says it's a waste of practice time, thank it for the input, and keep playing anyway.
Pssst... if the moving goalposts sound familiar, Perfectionism in Musicians might be worth a read too.
5. "Being hard on myself is what got me here"
Okay, maybe...
Or maybe you got here despite it.
Your talent, your hours and your love for the music did a lot of the heavy lifting. They'll keep working without the inner drill sergeant.
I understand why this belief holds on. That harsh voice is a part of your mind that's trying to keep you safe.
And at some point, it probably seemed to work. You were hard on yourself, you got better, and the two got linked. The trouble is that the same voice tends to come with you on stage, right when you need your attention on the music. "That was shaky. Here comes the hard part. Don't mess this up."
You can keep high standards and still change the tone you use with yourself. Think about how you'd talk to a student you believed in after a rough lesson. You'd be honest with them (we don't need to sugarcoat anything), but you'd also be kind, right? Because you'd know they learn better that way.
The experiment: The next time the critic starts up, ask yourself, "Would I say this to a student?" If the answer is no, try saying it the way you would to them. It might feel a bit strange at first. That's fine.
If you'd like to read more about what builds steadiness on stage, Performance Confidence: What It Is and How Musicians Build It is a good next step.
6. "Everyone else in my section seems totally fine. It must be just me"
They're probably hiding stress just as well as you are.
(Admit it, you don't want to show weakness or talk about it either :) )
Well, you're comparing how you feel inside to how everyone else looks from the outside. And from the outside, almost everyone looks fine.
One of the musicians I've worked with was a first-chair flutist in a major orchestra. She was respected by her colleagues and known for her preparation and precision, the kind of player a section could trust completely. But inside, she felt deeply judged in exposed passages: By colleagues, by audiences, and sometimes by no one in particular but herself. In section meetings, she held back, half from politeness and half from a sense that her opinion needed earning. (You can read her story here.)
Somebody in your section might be looking at you right now and thinking you're the one who has it all together.
The experiment: Pick one colleague you trust, and share one small, honest thing after a rehearsal. "That passage always makes me nervous" is enough. You don't need to tell your whole story. Just notice what happens.
Why You Compare Yourself to Other Musicians goes deeper into this one.
Where these ideas come from
If you caught yourself nodding at more than one of these, that's no coincidence. Most of us learned them in the same rooms, from people who learned them in the same rooms before us.
You can be a "real" musician and still put some of them down.
An invitation ☕️
If you'd like support leaving some of these patterns behind, a Performance Strategy Session is a good place to start: One 90-minute session focused on your performing and what you'd like to change about it.
About
I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.
Quick answers
Is it normal to cry after practicing music?
It's common, and an occasional frustrated moment is human. If practice regularly ends in tears, it's worth looking at what you're telling yourself while you practice, and whether each session has turned into a verdict on you.
Do professional musicians get nervous?
Yes, including very experienced ones. With the right skills, the nerves get in the way of the music much less.
Why do I play worse when people are listening?
Being heard changes what's happening in your body and where your attention goes. Playing while you're being listened to is a skill of its own, and most musicians rarely get to practice it.
Do you need to be hard on yourself to improve?
High standards help. Harshness tends to get in the way, especially on stage, where a critical inner voice pulls your attention away from the music. You can be honest about what needs work and still be kind in how you say it.








