top of page

"Be More Expressive": How to Act on Feedback That Doesn't Tell You What to Do

Aug 25
7 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Dark slide with the title "Be More Expressive": How to Act on Feedback That Doesn't Tell You What to Do, beside a watercolor of a loose stack of sheet music with a blue pencil and an eraser resting on top.
* Where I describe clients in my blog posts, I've changed names, instruments, and other identifying details to protect their privacy. Sometimes I'm describing one person, sometimes a pattern I've seen across several. The essence of the experience and what we worked on together remain true.

More musical. More energy. Say something with it. Be more engaging.


If you've had lessons, masterclasses or audition feedback for any length of time, you've collected a few of these...


Many of the musicians I work with, especially the quieter ones, have heard them for years. And almost all of them have the same reaction: OK, but what do I actually DO?


When a client tells me they've been asked to move more, my first question is always: Move more and do what? Until that has an answer, the feedback isn't really actionable.


Unfortunately, vague feedback is very common... but it's fixable, because expression is made of things you can choose.



Why expression so often gets left vague


It isn't only you. When researchers in Sweden filmed real instrumental lessons, they found the teaching focused "mainly on technique and on the written score", and that expression and emotion were "mostly dealt with implicitly rather than explicitly". They also noted a general lack of clear goals and specific tasks (Karlsson & Juslin, 2008).


So many of us learned expression by osmosis. A teacher played it for us, or said "more!", or sighed in a particular way, and we were left to work out what they meant.


A study with young instrumentalists showed how much a single question can change that. Many of the pupils had never thought about the character of the pieces they were playing, and for some of them the music had been "just notes". Being asked what the character of the music was, and how to show it, was described as an eye-opener (Meissner et al., 2021). Granted, those pupils were children, but I see a grown-up version of the same thing in professional musicians all the time.



What listeners actually hear


Expression can feel mysterious, but a lot of it comes down to a handful of things the audience can hear.


In one study, three professional guitarists played short melodies to express anger, sadness, happiness and fear, and 30 listeners rated what they heard. The listeners picked up the intended emotion very well, and they did it through four main cues: Tempo, sound level, articulation and tone color. Loudness mattered most. Sadness, for example, went with slower tempos and more legato playing (Juslin, 2000).


The part I find most encouraging is that two of the guitarists communicated equally well while using the cues in different ways. There wasn't one correct recipe. A later review of 41 studies on music performance found the same kind of consistent link between emotions and these concrete sound properties (Juslin & Laukka, 2003).


So when a panel writes "more expressive", they're often hearing that these choices are too small, too similar from phrase to phrase, or not connected to what the music is about.



Images help, once you translate them


Teachers, especially voice teachers, often reach for images instead: Play it like a sunrise. Sing it as if you're telling a secret.


These can be wonderful, but they can also leave you just as lost as "more musical".


Robert Woody has studied this for years. In one study, 84 music students practiced melodies after receiving imagery-based instructions. Some of them turned the images into explicit plans for the sound itself, while others kept the image as a personal feeling (Woody, 2006). In a more recent study, expressiveness ratings rose after imagery-based instruction, and the musicians who did the most of that translating improved the most (Woody et al., 2024).


The same study found something every musician should know. Sometimes players felt they had changed their performance, but the listeners couldn't hear any difference (Woody et al., 2024). What you intend and what reaches the room can be quite far apart.


One image can also do a lot of work on its own. A singer I worked with had a bright, bubbly aria, and the picture she chose was a little cherub hopping from cloud to cloud in a wide open sky, giggling on the way. We didn't translate it phrase by phrase. She held the whole picture, and it gave her a lot of freedom inside the aria. It also did something very concrete: Her high notes got lighter, freer, and she was having more fun with her little cherub image.



What helps


Here's what I suggest to the musicians I work with:


Ask where, and more of what


If you can, ask the person giving the feedback: "Can you show me one place where you wanted more?" It's a reasonable question and, in my experience, definitely worth asking.


Be ready for the answer to stay vague, though. A teacher or a panel member can have a very good ear for what's missing without having a recipe for how to put it in, and that happens more with experienced professionals, where the gap being heard is a small one. So assume you'll be doing the translating yourself, and treat whatever they say as a clue rather than a set of instructions.


Give each phrase a character


Go through the music, or the excerpt, and give each phrase or section one word for its character: Tender, restless, defiant, playful, resigned... one word is enough. If you're stuck, ask yourself what the phrase would be saying if it could speak.


Or go the other way, like the singer with her cherub, and find one picture for the whole piece that you keep in mind as you play or sing. Both work. A word per phrase gives you more control over the detail, while a single image gives you more freedom inside it, and some musicians like one picture with a word or two for the places that need something different.


Turn the word into sound


Then ask what that word means for the four things listeners hear. What does restless do to your tempo and timing? Does tender mean softer, or just a warmer color? Does defiant want shorter articulation, or more weight at the start of each note? Write the answers in your part, in pencil, the way you'd write fingerings or breaths.


Make the contrasts bigger than feels comfortable


Because what you intend and what the audience hears can be so far apart, practice your choices bigger than feels natural, then record yourself and listen back. More often than not, what felt like too much sounds about right. (There's more on this in Being Expressive Without Feeling Fake.)


Add the visual layer


Once the sound has a plan, the body can follow it. This is where the phrase-by-phrase plan from Too in Your Own Head? comes in: Arms a little more fluid in this section, a slight smile in that phrase, the back wall here... so that when nerves arrive on stage, you have something specific to come back to, instead of a vague more.



From "more" to a plan


The feedback you've been given is usually pointing at something real that would make a difference to your performances... it just stops one step short. When you fill in that step yourself, with a word for each phrase and a few concrete choices for the sound, "be more expressive" turns into something you can actually practice.


Expression doesn't have to arrive as inspiration. You can build it, phrase by phrase, and then let it feel like yours.



An invitation ☕️


If you keep getting feedback like "more musical" or "more energy" and you'd like help turning it into a plan, a Performance Strategy Session is one 90-minute session where we can go through your repertoire or excerpts together and decide what each phrase is asking for, so you walk in with choices of your own.





About


I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.




Quick answers


How can I be more expressive when I play or sing?


Give each phrase one word for its character, then decide what that word means for your tempo and timing, dynamics, articulation and tone color. Practice those choices a little bigger than feels natural, and check them on a recording.


What does "more musical" mean in feedback?


It usually means the listener heard the notes but not a clear intention behind them. Your choices of tempo, dynamics, articulation and tone color may be too small, or too similar from phrase to phrase.


Why don't teachers explain expression more clearly?


Research on instrumental lessons found teaching focused mainly on technique and the written score, with expression mostly handled implicitly. Many teachers learned expression the same way themselves.


Why can't the panel hear the changes I made?


What you intend and what listeners hear can be quite different. In one study, some musicians felt they had changed their playing when listeners couldn't hear a difference, so record yourself and make your choices clearer.



Research cited


  • Juslin, P. N. (2000). Cue utilization in communication of emotion in music performance: Relating performance to perception. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 26(6), 1797–1813. https://doi.org/10.1037/0096-1523.26.6.1797

  • Juslin, P. N., & Laukka, P. (2003). Communication of emotions in vocal expression and music performance: Different channels, same code? Psychological Bulletin, 129(5), 770–814. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.129.5.770

  • Karlsson, J., & Juslin, P. N. (2008). Musical expression: An observational study of instrumental teaching. Psychology of Music, 36(3), 309–334. https://doi.org/10.1177/0305735607086040

  • Meissner, H., Timmers, R., & Pitts, S. E. (2021). "Just notes": Young musicians' perspectives on learning expressive performance. Research Studies in Music Education, 43(3), 451–464. https://doi.org/10.1177/1321103X19899171

  • Woody, R. H. (2006). Musicians' cognitive processing of imagery-based instructions for expressive performance. Journal of Research in Music Education, 54(2), 125–137. https://doi.org/10.1177/002242940605400204

  • Woody, R. H., Hilbers, M. B., Schreiner, J., & Schuck, A. D. (2024). The efficacy of imagery-based instruction for expressive performance: A study of university musicians' practice. Music Education Research, 26(5), 622–633. https://doi.org/10.1080/14613808.2024.2384370


Letters On 
Music, Practice & Mindset

Trusted by 300+ musicians in 19+ countries and counting...

34_edited.jpg
Kuki & Annie.png

Cute(ish) Tax:

The judgmental team

Absolutely no spam, and you can easily unsubscribe anytime. Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared with anyone. 

Every Tuesday morning, a Letter lands in your inbox — a short read with stories from the coaching studio, ideas worth thinking about, and the kind of perspective that helps you show up steadier on stage and off.

​

Sometimes I'll share a small gift, point you to a new piece I've written, or let you know when I'm opening up coaching spots or creating something you might want in on.

​

Oh... and you’ll get exclusive access to my cats’ most judgmental photos. Obviously.

bottom of page