top of page

Too in Your Own Head? Expressive Performing for Introverted Musicians

Aug 18
9 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Dark slide with the title Too in Your Own Head? Expressive Performing for Introverted Musicians, beside a watercolor of a head in profile with soft pastel swirls inside and a single line trailing out toward the edge.
* Where I describe clients in my blog posts, I've changed names, instruments, and other identifying details to protect their privacy. Sometimes I'm describing one person, sometimes a pattern I've seen across several. The essence of the experience and what we worked on together remain true.

I'm an introvert, and most of the musicians I work with are on the quieter side too.


Many of them have heard some version of the same feedback over the years:

You're too in your own head. You need more energy. Move around more. Make eye contact.


And left to their own devices, a lot of them do the opposite of what that feedback asks. They close their eyes and try to get lost in the music.


If that sounds familiar, there's a LOT you can do about it without turning into someone else.



I used to close my eyes too


When I started taking classical singing lessons, I sang with my eyes closed.


It felt like the most natural thing in the world: I could hear myself better, I didn't have to deal with anyone's face, and the music felt closer.


My teachers corrected it straight away. Close your eyes when you're recording, they said, or at home when you're practicing, if it helps you focus. But not on stage.


So I found a workaround. Every time I sang for people, I blurred my gaze and pretended I couldn't see them. From the inside it didn't work, because I could still see them. From the outside, it looked infinitely better.


But there was a big gap between how it felt and how it looked... which turned out to matter a lot.



Musicians are often introverts


Research on musicians' personalities goes back decades, and introversion keeps coming up. Anthony Kemp compared music students, professional musicians and non-musicians, and found introversion was the most strongly expressed personality trait among musicians, along with sensitivity and anxiety (Kemp, 1996).


There are differences between instruments, too. Kemp found violinists more introverted than pianists and singers, and later studies have found singers score higher on extraversion than instrumentalists (Butković, 2024). (As an introverted singer, I seem to be the exception there.)


In a 2023 YouGov poll of 1,000 American adults, almost twice as many people described themselves as introverts (39%) as extroverts (22%), and most of the rest said they were an equal mix of both (Ballard, 2023). So in any orchestra, chorus or audition waiting room, you're very unlikely to be the only one.


Side note: Many of my clients also describe themselves as highly sensitive. Loud rooms, bright lights and a lot of eyes on them take more out of them than they seem to take out of the people around them. Elaine and Arthur Aron first described this trait (Aron & Aron, 1997), and early estimates put it at around 15 to 20% of people (Greven et al., 2019). (It deserves a post of its own, which you can read here.)



Introversion and shyness are different things


It helps to be clear about what introversion is, because it often gets mixed up with being shy, or with not being "a performer type".


Cain describes introverts as people who prefer quieter, less stimulating environments. Shyness is something else, a fear of being judged, and it can be uncomfortable for introverts and extraverts alike (Cain, 2012). Introversion itself is about how much input you enjoy before you need some quiet.


Nothing in that definition says you can't be expressive. Introverts often feel music with great depth. The challenge is about where your attention goes on stage, and how much a room full of people costs you.


The psychologist Brian Little describes himself as "a classic introvert", and yet, he says, "when I give a lecture for my students I perform with great passion" (Lambert, 2003). (I was exactly the same way back when I was a lecturer!) His idea is that we can act out of character for the things we care about most. He also says that people often can't tell the difference between a born extravert and an introvert who's "on".


The catch, according to Little, is that acting out of character for long stretches "exacts a price" unless you have a "restorative niche" to recover in. His own was a quiet break in the washroom after lecturing (Lambert, 2003). For me, it was heading to the break room to grab a cup of tea, of course.



Why closing your eyes feels right, and what the audience sees


For an introverted or sensitive performer, closing your eyes makes a lot of sense. It cuts down the input, takes the faces out of the picture, and lets you go somewhere private with the music.


From the audience's side, though, it can look as if you've gone somewhere they're not invited. The music may be beautiful, but the door is closed. (If you've read Audiences See Before They Hear, you'll know how much what people see shapes what they hear.)


There's research on this. In one study, a musician performed the same pieces while turning his gaze toward the audience to different degrees. When he looked at the audience more, listeners liked the music more and rated him as more expressive and more communicative, whether he was singing and playing or only playing (Antonietti et al., 2009).


In another study, listeners rated classical performances they could see higher than the same performances heard as audio only, and said they'd be more likely to come to a future recital (Noppe, 2012).


So the eyes-closed habit can feel like the most expressive thing you do, and still come across to the audience as the least.



Why "move more" and "make eye contact" tend to backfire


When teachers and panels say more energy or make eye contact, they're often right about what they're seeing. The trouble is what the performer does with it.


"Move more" describes a result without giving you anything to do. So on stage, especially when you're nervous, the thought becomes I should move more, and you start adding movement at random: A sway here, a lift of the shoulders there, a glance at someone in the third row that you regret at once...


And now you're watching yourself from the outside while you play or sing, which is the "too in your own head" problem the feedback was meant to fix :)


It's also a lot to ask of an introvert. Being told to look more outgoing can feel like being asked to perform as someone else, and that tends to feel fake from the inside, even when it looks fine from the outside.



What helps


Here's what I suggest to the musicians I work with.


As always, these are experiments: Keep what helps and drop the rest.


Look at the back wall


Try looking toward the very back wall of the hall, just over people's heads. From the audience, it reads as if you're looking out at them and including them. From the stage, you're not meeting anyone's eyes, so it costs you much less. This has worked for a lot of my clients, and it's a big improvement on the blurred gaze I used to rely on.


Practice with your eyes open


If you close your eyes on stage, chances are you close them in the practice room, in rehearsals and in your section too, whenever you think nobody's watching. And what you do when you're not being seen is what you'll fall back on when you are.


So practice with your eyes open, on purpose, until it stops feeling strange. If you've always played or sung with your eyes closed, start small: One phrase with your eyes open, looking toward a point on the wall, then a few more.


Give "move more" a direction


This is the one I spend the most time on with clients. We go through the music, or the excerpt, phrase by phrase, and decide what each part asks for. It might look something like this:


  • In this section, let your arms move a little more fluidly.

  • In this phrase, a slight smile.

  • Here, look up toward the back wall.


It's almost choreographed, without being strict. Think of it as a North Star, a direction you keep walking in, more than a set of positions to hit.


Where it helps most is under pressure. When you notice you're getting self-conscious or nervous, and the old thought arrives (I should be moving more), you have something specific to turn your attention toward. You go back to what you planned for that phrase, and your attention is back on the music.


Let the movement come from the music


The choices that work best come from the score, from the character of a phrase and where it's going. A crescendo might lift your chest a little, and a long line might let your arms soften. Movement that grows out of the music looks natural, because it is.


Step into your performer-self


You don't have to become an extravert to perform well. The performer you are on stage is a part of you, and you can practice stepping into it, the way Brian Little steps into his lectures. I wrote more about this in How to Perform Freely and Confidently.


Check it on video


What feels enormous from the inside often looks quite modest from the outside, and the only way to know is to watch. Record a run-through, watch it back, and notice where your eyes and your body were. Listening to Recordings of Yourself has some ideas for doing that kindly.


Plan your restorative niche


I also think Little is right: You'll need somewhere to recover after performing, and often before it too. That might be a quiet corner, a walk with headphones on, or a few minutes alone in the bathroom (the Brian Little approach!). Building that into your day is part of performing well as an introvert, and I'll write more about it in a later post.



Quiet performers


Some of the most moving performances I've seen came from people who would never call themselves outgoing. What they had was a clear sense of where their attention was going, and a way of letting the audience in on it.


You can keep your quiet nature and still leave the door open for the audience.



An invitation ☕️


If you've been told you're too in your own head and you'd like a plan that suits how you're wired, a Performance Strategy Session is one 90-minute session where we can go through your music phrase by phrase together and decide where your eyes and body go, so you have something clear to come back to on stage.





About


I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.




Quick answers


Can introverts be good performers?


Yes. Research has found introversion is common among musicians, and introversion is about how much stimulation you enjoy, which says nothing about how expressive you can be. Many introverted musicians perform with great expression once they have a clear focus for their attention.


Is it bad to close your eyes when performing?


It's fine in the practice room or when recording, if it helps you focus. On stage, it can leave the audience feeling shut out. In one study, listeners rated a performer as more expressive and communicative when he looked toward the audience.


How do I make eye contact with the audience if it makes me nervous?


You don't need direct eye contact. Looking toward the back wall, just over people's heads, reads to the audience as looking out at them and costs you far less.


What does "too in your own head" mean in performance feedback?


It usually means the audience can see you're focused inward, with your eyes closed or your gaze down, and they feel left out of the music. A phrase-by-phrase plan for where your eyes and body go gives you something outward to focus on.



Research cited



Letters On 
Music, Practice & Mindset

Trusted by 300+ musicians in 19+ countries and counting...

34_edited.jpg
Kuki & Annie.png

Cute(ish) Tax:

The judgmental team

Absolutely no spam, and you can easily unsubscribe anytime. Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared with anyone. 

Every Tuesday morning, a Letter lands in your inbox — a short read with stories from the coaching studio, ideas worth thinking about, and the kind of perspective that helps you show up steadier on stage and off.

​

Sometimes I'll share a small gift, point you to a new piece I've written, or let you know when I'm opening up coaching spots or creating something you might want in on.

​

Oh... and you’ll get exclusive access to my cats’ most judgmental photos. Obviously.

bottom of page