top of page

Being Expressive Without Feeling Fake

Sep 1
7 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Dark slide with the title Being Expressive Without Feeling Fake, beside a watercolor of novelty disguise glasses with a big pink nose, bushy eyebrows and a mustache.
* Where I describe clients in my blog posts, I've changed names, instruments, and other identifying details to protect their privacy. Sometimes I'm describing one person, sometimes a pattern I've seen across several. The essence of the experience and what we worked on together remain true.

I once sang a popular song in a concert and decided, beforehand, that I'd been moving around too much...


So I sat down for it. Safer, I thought, and less distracting.


It was dull. Watching it back, I could see there was room for far more than I'd allowed myself, and that the thing I'd been so careful to avoid wouldn't have been a problem at all.


That gap between what I was sure I looked like and what was actually there is at the heart of a worry many quieter musicians carry.


They're told to be more expressive, to move more, to show more, and part of them pulls back: If I do that, I'll look ridiculous. It won't be me. I'll come across as fake.


That worry makes complete sense, because it's often based on a picture of yourself that the audience never sees.



You can't see yourself from the audience


Psychologists have a name for one part of this: The illusion of transparency. People tend to believe their inner states "leak out" more than they really do. In a series of studies, people overestimated how well others could tell when they were lying or when they were disgusted by what they were tasting (Gilovich et al., 1998).


The same thing happens with nerves. Public speakers believed their nervousness was more visible to the audience than it was, and when speakers were told about this illusion before speaking, both they and the observers rated their speeches as better (Savitsky & Gilovich, 2003).


A related finding, the spotlight effect, shows that people overestimate how much others notice their appearance and their actions at all (Gilovich et al., 2000).


None of these studies were about musicians, but I see the same pattern on stage. What feels like a huge gesture from the inside often looks modest from the outside, and the nerves you're sure everyone can see are often far less obvious than you think.


The researcher Jane Davidson, who studied performers' movements in detail, put it this way: "The performer has partial knowledge of the movements he makes" (Davidson, 1991).



Holding still doesn't make you invisible


When you're worried about looking fake, it can seem safest to do as little as possible. And apparently, the audience can read that too :)


Davidson filmed solo musicians playing the same piece in different manners, from deadpan to projected to exaggerated. Observers who only watched, without sound, could tell the performer's intended manner, and vision showed it more clearly than sound alone (Davidson, 1993). Even when the performers were reduced to points of light on their joints, movement alone was enough to tell the manners apart (Davidson, 1991).


In a study with marimba players, audiences rated the projected performances as more expressive and more interesting than the deadpan ones. Seeing the performer made the projected versions even more expressive, while the deadpan versions came across as less expressive with video than with sound alone (Broughton & Stevens, 2009).


So the camera, or the audience, tends to amplify whatever you're actually doing. A still, careful performer doesn't look lost in the music, or like they're enjoying it. They look still and careful.



Where "fake" comes from


The feeling of fakeness usually comes from adding things on top: A smile you don't mean, a sway because someone said to move, a dramatic face for a phrase you haven't decided anything about.


There's an interesting parallel in research on emotional labor, the effort of showing certain emotions as part of a job. Researchers distinguish surface acting, changing only your outward display, from deep acting, actually working up the feeling you want to show. In a study of service workers, surface acting went with more exhaustion and with coworkers rating the person's delivery as less convincing, while deep acting did not (Grandey, 2003). A review of 95 studies found the same pattern: Surface acting was linked to emotional exhaustion, and deep acting only slightly (Hülsheger & Schewe, 2011).


A concert hall isn't a shop counter, so I'd take this with a grain of salt. But I think it explains a lot about why "move more" feels so wrong to so many musicians. Movement added from the outside is surface acting. Movement that comes from what you've decided the music is saying is much closer to deep acting, and it tends to feel like yours.



What helps


Here's what I suggest to the musicians I work with:


Start from the music


Before you think about your body, decide what each phrase is about. One word for its character is enough, and then you can work out what that means for your sound. (I wrote about how to do this in "Be More Expressive".) Once the music has a clear intention, the movement has something to grow out of.


Turn the dial up in the practice room


Pick a short passage and play or sing it three ways: As still as you can, the way you usually play or sing it, and with everything turned up more than feels comfortable. Record all three on video.


Then watch them back as if they were someone else. Many musicians find the "too much" version looks natural, or even a little restrained, and that the version they thought was normal looks quite flat.


With clients I usually ask for an 11 out of 10, and the answer I get afterwards is almost always the same: It was maybe a 7. A performer who is certain they've just been too loud, too obnoxious, too ridiculous watches the video and finds something that looks perfectly reasonable, and often rather small for a big stage. (I've had the same experience myself, and so has every musical friend I've asked.)


Take it in small steps


You don't have to jump straight to the biggest version. Choose one phrase per piece where you let the expression come out more, and once that feels ordinary, add another. Small changes, repeated, start to feel like part of how you perform.


Borrow a trusted pair of eyes


Ask a colleague, teacher or friend to watch and tell you where it looked convincing and where it looked put on. Their answer is often kinder than the one in your head.


Let your performer-self help


The version of you on stage is still you, with permission to be bigger. If that idea is new, How to Perform Freely and Confidently goes into it in more detail, and Too in Your Own Head? has ideas for where to look and how to give "move more" a direction.


Remember the illusion when nerves show up


If you're worried everyone can see you shaking or blushing, remind yourself that they very likely can't see as much as you feel. Knowing that helped the speakers in Savitsky and Gilovich's study, and it often takes some pressure off performers too.



Expression you can stand behind


Feeling fake is a useful signal... it often means the expression is coming from instructions rather than from the music. When you start from what each phrase means to you, and then check how it looks from the outside, you can be more visible on stage without becoming someone else.


What feels like too much from the inside is often just enough for the back row.



An invitation ☕️


If being more expressive on stage feels fake or exposing, a Performance Strategy Session is one 90-minute session where we can work out what your music is saying and how much of it can reach the audience, in a way that still feels like you.





About


I'm Gökçe Kutsal, a music performance coach for professional orchestra musicians and opera singers, with an MA in Voice Pedagogy, plus coaching and teaching experience since 2017. I work with orchestral musicians, soloists, and audition candidates across Europe, the UK, North America, and Australia — and I write about performance anxiety, audition preparation, and the craft of practice for musicians who already have the technique and are trying to work out why it doesn't always hold up under pressure.




Quick answers


Why does being expressive on stage feel fake?


Usually because the expression is being added on top, like moving because you were told to move. When movement and expression come from a clear intention for each phrase, they tend to feel much more like yours.


How can I tell if I'm being too expressive?


Record yourself on video, including a version with everything turned up more than feels comfortable. Many musicians find the "too much" version looks natural from the outside.


Can the audience see how nervous I am?


Usually less than you think. Research on public speakers found they overestimated how visible their nervousness was, and knowing this helped them give better speeches.


Is it better to stay still if I'm not sure how to move?


Not necessarily. In studies of musicians, audiences rated deadpan performances as less expressive, and video made that stillness more noticeable. Small movements that grow out of the music usually read better.



Research cited


  • Broughton, M., & Stevens, C. (2009). Music, movement and marimba: An investigation of the role of movement and gesture in communicating musical expression to an audience. Psychology of Music, 37(2), 137–153. https://doi.org/10.1177/0305735608094511

  • Davidson, J. W. (1991). The perception of expressive movement in music performance [Doctoral thesis, City University London]. City Research Online. https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/7725/

  • Davidson, J. W. (1993). Visual perception of performance manner in the movements of solo musicians. Psychology of Music, 21(2), 103–113. https://doi.org/10.1177/030573569302100201

  • Gilovich, T., Medvec, V. H., & Savitsky, K. (2000). The spotlight effect in social judgment: An egocentric bias in estimates of the salience of one's own actions and appearance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78(2), 211–222. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.78.2.211

  • Gilovich, T., Savitsky, K., & Medvec, V. H. (1998). The illusion of transparency: Biased assessments of others' ability to read one's emotional states. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(2), 332–346. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.75.2.332

  • Grandey, A. A. (2003). When "the show must go on": Surface acting and deep acting as determinants of emotional exhaustion and peer-rated service delivery. Academy of Management Journal, 46(1), 86–96. https://doi.org/10.2307/30040678

  • Hülsheger, U. R., & Schewe, A. F. (2011). On the costs and benefits of emotional labor: A meta-analysis of three decades of research. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 16(3), 361–389. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0022876

  • Savitsky, K., & Gilovich, T. (2003). The illusion of transparency and the alleviation of speech anxiety. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 39(6), 618–625. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-1031(03)00056-8


Letters On 
Music, Practice & Mindset

Trusted by 300+ musicians in 19+ countries and counting...

34_edited.jpg
Kuki & Annie.png

Cute(ish) Tax:

The judgmental team

Absolutely no spam, and you can easily unsubscribe anytime. Your information is 100% secure and will never be shared with anyone. 

Every Tuesday morning, a Letter lands in your inbox — a short read with stories from the coaching studio, ideas worth thinking about, and the kind of perspective that helps you show up steadier on stage and off.

​

Sometimes I'll share a small gift, point you to a new piece I've written, or let you know when I'm opening up coaching spots or creating something you might want in on.

​

Oh... and you’ll get exclusive access to my cats’ most judgmental photos. Obviously.

bottom of page